<xmp id="e0aoq">
<menu id="e0aoq"></menu>
  • <blockquote id="e0aoq"></blockquote>
  • 歡迎來到中國政府采購網/中國政府購買服務信息平臺-浙江省分網站! 服務熱線:400-881-7190

    浙江政府采購網 > 采購知識 > 問題解答 > 特定金額的合同業績可以作為評審因素嗎?

    特定金額的合同業績可以作為評審因素嗎?

    來源:政府采購信息網 發布時間:2019-04-15 瀏覽次數:

           采購文件將特定金額的合同業績設置為評審因素,屬于《政府采購法實施條例》第二十條規定的“以不合理的條件對供應商實行差別待遇或者歧視待遇”的情形嗎?

     

      先來看一個案例:

     

      某高校校園網絡機房設備購置項目,采購預算140萬元,采用競爭性磋商采購方式。磋商文件評分標準中規定,投標供應商要提供2015年1月1日以后完成的類似項目業績情況。合同金額在200(含)萬元以上的,每個項目得2分;合同金額在150萬(含)—200萬之間的,每個項目得1.5分;依次類推。合同金額在50萬以下的不得分。評標現場供應商必須提供合同或中標通知書原件,中標通知書必須在有效期內,不提供原件不得分。

     

      這就是業內經常討論的一個問題:特定金額的合同業績可以作為評審因素嗎?采購文件中的這類規定合法合規嗎?對此,有兩種截然不同的看法。

     

      一種看法認為,特定金額的合同作為評審因素有其合理性。

     

      理由是:評標委員會可以根據不同金額合同的履行情況來評判供應商的履約能力。磋商文件對投標人履行合同的大與小進行高與低的打分,旨在評價供應商的履約能力和專業水平。本案例中,既沒有規定合同的特定行政區域,又沒有指明特定的行業,而且特定金額的合同業績也不是實質性條款。這個規定不存在指向性、行業排斥性以及區域排斥性。所以,可以對合同大小金額打出高低不同的分值,以此評價投標人履行能力的強弱。

     

      同意的人還認為,綜合評分法的實質,就是以相關因素為衡量指標把投標供應商分出高低,然后對供應商的履約能力做出優劣評價。當然啦,前提是對所有潛在供應商一視同仁,不偏向不排斥。評標本來就是一種優勝劣汰,評分因素只要是圍繞購買貨物、工程和服務的質量進行設定,就具有合理性。

     

      另一種觀點認為,不應將特定金額合同作為評審因素。

     

      特定金額的合同業績不可以作為供應商的資格條件,也不能作為評審的實質性條件,這是毋容置疑的。特定金額的合同雖然不是直接針對的企業規模,但由于合同金額與營業收入直接相關,其實質是通過營業收入對中小企業進行限制,構成對中小企業實行差別待遇或者歧視待遇。新注冊、暫時沒有業績、業績很少的供應商可能問:我暫時沒有業績或者合同不大,但就一定證明我完不成這單合同嗎?

     

      我們知道,中小企業對國民經濟和社會發展有著重要戰略意義。中小企業是實施大眾創業、萬眾創新的重要載體,在增加就業、促進經濟增長、科技創新與社會和諧穩定等方面具有不可替代的作用。上繳稅收占全國稅收總額的50%,創造的GDP占全國GDP的60%, 70%的技術創新由中小企業完成,中小企業還提供了80%的就業崗位。

     

      案例中磋商文件存在一個很大的問題,就是要求提供特定金額的合同業績,特別是業績評分項的最后一條:“合同金額在50萬以下不得分”。為何不得分?這一條明顯不合理。發揮政府采購的政策功能,大力促進中小企業發展的時代背景之下,磋商文件把供應商50萬元以下的業績分歸零,于法無據,于理不通,顯失公平,實屬不妥。

     

      在采購實踐中,采購人認為需要供應商具有類似業績作為加分條件的,一是可以設置全國性的非特定行業的類似業績為評審因素。二是可以從項目本身具有的技術特性和實際需要出發,對供應商提出類似業績要求作為評審加分標準,前提是不帶合同金額。

     

      我認可第二種意見,采購人可以要求供應商提供類似的合同業績,但是不得要求提供特定金額的合同業績作為評審因素的。

     

      財政部政府采購信息公告第六百五十九號認定,將特定金額的合同業績設置為評審因素,屬于《政府采購法實施條例》第二十條規定的“以不合理的條件對供應商實行差別待遇或者歧視待遇”的情形。

     

      親愛的政府采購同行,你對這個問題有什么看法呢?歡迎大家轉發本期音頻并在留言板上互動留言,也歡迎大家把采購實戰中遇到的各種疑難雜癥,在易采通APP2.4版有問有答頻道提出。


    相關文章

    返回頂部
    256彩票 www.bet73x.com | www.660tk.com | www.11310.cc | www.88266p.com | www.81233i.com | bst979.com | www.8998885.com | 14140524.com | www.hg7861.com | www.671075.com | 159666m.com | www.j83377.com | 88304k.com | www.33384066.com | www.igcp6.com | 86811o.com | www.9464004.com | 83377e.com | www.330099u.com | www.096wy.com | www.qm72.com | JS1388z.com | www.vnsr378.com | 3404p.cc | www.jjjj006.com | www.3116n.com | www.308680.com | www.7435j.com | www.003ac.com | 73055m.com | www.9187v.com | wns789.net | www.27799a.com | www.86267a.com | www.hg6789.com | www.61233z.com | 4288cc.com | www.js79905.com | dh2894.com | www.166663.com | 5004fff.com | www.6555a.com | www.641377.com | 8742a.com | www.089b.cc | z2490.com | www.39500hh.com | 36408833.com | www.ya2019w.com | 55323i.com | www.1851117.com | 9030i.com | www.4496877.com | 6245w.com | www.kk1778.com | www.170955.com | www.544442.com | www.582993.com | 6766hh.com | www.660727.com | www.369888aa.com | www.www6161msccom.com | www.739366.com | www.pjanhui.com | www.55060g.com | www.caim5.com | 6692.am | www.085wy.com | 80900.com | www.50064b.com | 2381dd.com | www.39500n.com | 9977977.com | www.9205c.com | www.702392.com | 52599n.com | www.50051c.com | 588nnn.cc | www.00840j.com | 88807l.com | www.978137.com | www.0636c.com | www.lcw199.com | www.47272x.com | 22291166.com | www.998855u.com | 0199955.com | www.4058gg.com | bet577.com | www.blr9944.com | 112z.net | www.c9335.com | www.7720e.com | www.345576.com | www.318008.com | 1408q.com | www.45598j.com | fff5701.com | www.2418g.com | 500000515.com | www.yi328.com | www.58777g.com | 5003xx.com | www.yh8878a.com | 060ccc.com | www.hn896.com | 3178gg.com | www.811597.com | www.0009193.com | 6641qq.com | www.55070l.com | 1489l.com | www.5091q.com | www.hg123888.com | 55ll8331.com | www.4102u.com | 998h.cc | www.866309.com | www.33623a.com | 37570z.com | www.vns11.me | 44ms888.com | 22291166.com | www.766169.com | ppp7570.com | www.cf9901.com | www.hg5600.com | 9030o.com | www.883399h.com | 87665j.com | www.346077.com | www.234k7.com | 3559fff.com | www.9356j.com | www.js520456.com | vvv444000.com | www.764169.com | www.1112xj.com | 2506h.com | www.2566y4.com | 3189vip.com | www.262548.com | www.8967d.com | ss224.com | www.366098.com | www.sscb00.cc | gg7742.com | www.580820.com | www.983098.com | 666789.com | www.606510.com | www.mhcp.com | 6766ii.com | www.436106.com | www.6880ll.com | 55ii8332.com | 9649y.com | www.30350b.com | w0595.com | 131g.net | www.77210j.com | www.25288r.com | 2805i.com | www.c5237.com | www.rycp157.com | 6868gg.cc | 131nn.net | www.hg28866.com | www.4107v.com | y52777.com | www.66ckb.com | www.e526688.com | 5804n.com | 99wb8.com | www.0883888.com | www.255251.com | blr135.com | www.618477.com | www.9737hh.me | 7141hh.com | 11005h.com | www.5441m.com | www.6882f.com | qianma9.cn | www.66332i.com | www.h36555.com | www.sun000.com | 4165i.com | www.444072.com | www.r2894.com | www.830678.com | 8016aa.com | www.62118e.com | www.8zz66.com | www.hg2219.com | 22098n.com | 31325b.com | www.77114h.com | www.3029.com | 30019r.com | 1463n.com | www.914905.com | www.47506l.com | www.222380.com | shenlaoxi.com | 112k.net | www.33112k.com | www.65066ee.com | www.hgw2088.net | 5360w.com | 29918c.com | www.39500s.com | www.f72.com | www.22567.com | 4488w.com | 66775004.com | www.870080a.com | www.88325r.com | www.hxcp300.com | 3178ff.com | 33771381.com | www.318073.com | www.89777o.com | www.33115rr.com | www.0686111.com | 4370.com | 11422.com | www.755814.com | www.9422d.com | www.50999j.com | www.boma0111.com | 22002007.com | dzj.tw | 98955g.com | www.055p.cc | www.883399c.com | www.50170vip1.com | www.ylg4444.com | y088.cc | 1389zz.com | www.106607.com | www.5854t.cc | www.5856869.com | www.dzcp6666.com | www.ljw037.com | le888m.com | vic6308.com | 259009.com | www.979683.com | www.hg8889.tw | www.07bet8.com | www.ms9998.com | 1064f.com | 7003u.com | pj600600.com | 73999b.com | www.456639.com | www.21202g.com | www.9187u.com | www.4972l.com | www.js466.com | www.yun770.com | ca7701.com | mm99911.net | ribo25.cc | 6698510.com | www.669634.com | www.60108h.com | www.9187b.com | www.163a66.com | www.87865.com | www.bl45.com | www.567pj.com | mgm3242w.com | 500000518.com | 1454445.com | 2v939.com | 4022w.com | 2018.so | www.346211.com | www.am7979.com | www.26878d.com | www.59348.com | www.js89l.vip | www.04567w.com | www.438666.com | www.959234.com | www.7830p.com | www.373xpj.com | gbhs44.com | www.55885g.com | www.hjcp444.com | www.789668.net | www.015647.com | www.hg88.us | www.365815m.com | www.v6866.com | www.68666k.com | 4116q.com | feicai0712.com | pj444.com | 22299rr.com | 00773l.com | 00558.com | 7003ww.com | 4590vv.com | 9068ww.com | 53358y.com | 7599q.com | js909.com | oo3336.com | 316q.cc | 56744.com | 54241100.com | by9911.com | 56988nn.com | 2287.com | www.38200a.com | www.70060000.com | www.2846i.com | www.ylzz1119.com | www.hg514.com | www.381818.com | www.93342.com | www.fh70.com | www.04567u.com | www.4996ty.com | www.2566y1.com | www.68993279.com | www.89894l.com | www.00840h.com | www.hcjt9.com | www.665771.com | www.215077.com | 2418006.com | 88851b.com | 91.ag | 1104007.com | 2757c.com | 66876q.com | www.28758f.com | www.777948.com | www.23470.com | www.ggz.99233z.com | www.7225b.com | www.7886263.com | www.77802r.com | www.hw8889.com | www.560923.com | 55331uu.com | 58802h.com | lll67890.com | 228888z.com | www.56733b.com | www.y2205.com | www.msc44.com | www.068717.com | www.yl1981.com | www.0014f.com | www.584511.com | 70118c.com | hhgz1144.com | 2190q.com | www.7720r.com | www.msc835.com | www.209035.com | www.9187l.com | www.39118.cc | www.348577.com | 15g9.net | 223blr.com | 50029988.com | www.56830f.com | www.9737ll.me | www.yl13434.com | www.944229.com | 9y88.vip | 4444c9.com | 66458q.com | www.107898.com | www.9170011.com | www.78700b.com | www.599810.com | 3568qq.com | 3467z.com | www.64400a.com | www.889tyc.com | www.w84r.com | www.c6078.com | 9411ggg.com | 3566bb.com | www.882235y.com | www.d22255.com | www.99094y.com | www.839991.com | dzhcpw.com | 8003aa.com | www.8694x.com | www.28000d.com | www.80075n.com | www.178652.com | 7893w49.com | 2805k.com | www.tm012.com | www.52062n.com | www.755745.com | 9649.com | 3178y.com | www.593333.com | www.1033.app | www.217113.com | c96sg2.com | www.876445.com | www.f72.com | www.34788l.com | jidupt.com | 3640bb.com | www.66930000.com | www.792085.com | www.602917.com | 867203.com | www.bet056365.com | www.o3065.com | www.37676.cc | ss4675.com | VIPVIP.cc | www.88184.com | www.585.cc | 243d9.com | dh0853.com | www.8706dd.com | www.37377z.com | www.43131r.com | 3030394.com | www.3616g.com | www.hd8678.com | 61789g.com | xpj61788.com | www.98msxfpt4.com | www.21202l.com | 9081.com | www.kf388.com | www.5446vv.com | www.938905.com | 0001164.com | www.390722.com | www.xpj53516.com | x7742.com | emr9836.com | www.2945i.com | www.hw8877.com | 61999pp.com | www.0860e.com | www.9422c.com | 3399vn77.com | 5509e.com | www.8080999g.com | www.55228i.com | 7276776.com | www.5049p.com | www.919709.com | 4182008.com | www.sun8777.com | www.75538d.com | ag80.vip | www.pj5506.com | www.4798.cc | 3678gg.com | www.hg77716.com | www.37377r.com | 5478z.com | www.63877b.com | www.7240e.com | 58335.com | www.6cw.org | www.2350.vip | yataibet5.com | www.223456f.com | www.89777a.com | 918dp.com | www.77537e.com | www.68689j.com | 5651x.com | www.11777999.com | www.hx6626.com | 3242k.com | www.1168b.com | www.263520.com | 2190w.com | www.8905r.com | 3775f.com | www.as0099.com | www.88266p.com | 81207.com | www.188614.com | www.701545.com | 3685m.com | www.88325i.com | lj552.com | www.00618p.com | www.9205a.com | uu01234.com | www.7415j.com | 01885j.com | www.653505.com | www.73736b.com | 5360w.com | www.rg999.com | 80850t.com | www.yh8333.com | www.37124.com | 53262vv.com | www.3188888.com | 7933311.com | www.1tgpd.com | www.959709.com | 3685m.com | www.20365vip.com | 28839k.com | www.cp67774.com | 701679.com | www.00829u.com | www.tlcp2.com | tt6824.com | www.1100.net | 4443865.com | www.b35ff.com | 8294d.com | www.xg808.cc | 80368hh.com | www.2226358.com | www.826925.com | jc3122.com | www.77803x.com | 33382a.com | www.67jsc.com | yth008.net | www.3577.ag | 4165f.com | www.6776dd.com | 8520g.com | www.hg99398.com | 835.cc | www.0022524.com | www.193723.com | www.7025q.com | www.621764.com | www.yddc666.com | www.937299.com | 00778f.com | www.qucw7.com | tyc1513.com | www.3933z.cc | 54140055.com | www.okw2.com | www.8058.la | www.978913.com | www.ylg292.com | www.918361.com | www.625966.com | www.914901.com | www.yh6008.com | www.809296.com | www.yh8888.cc | www.785382.com | www.935365.com | www.568001.com | www.d27229.com | www.190163.com | www.b5233.com | ln114.cc | www.hg743.com | 3434yyy.com | www.xm9900.com | q6q66.com | www.469700.com | hy756.com | www.4833041.com | 9958955.com | www.49956q.com | h4455g.com | www.701496.com | www.hg0092.com | 7811nn.com | www.871817.com | x8519.com | www.o32031.com | 4152u.com | www.77210f.com | 39830d.com | www.652361.com | www.44446609.com | 4379a.com | www.8473k.com | 915906728.com | www.4444bj.com | 6830c.com | www.613069.com | www.071097.com | wns883.net | www.47506r.com | uu7742.com | www.2934v.com | www.36536509.com | 4hg7788.com | www.4212l.com | m1915m.com | www.36788l.com | www.vns0800.com | www.139630.com | www.a98886.com | 2643z.com | www.9989578.com | 6601.cc | www.504077.com | www.228667.com | 5478m.com | www.9971i.com | 036010.com | www.305644.com | www.11223885.com | 69443322.com | www.33598w.com | www.3657c.com | pujingzaixianyule.com | www.673888x.com | 835a.cc | www.luck887.com | www.m15595.com | 2021k.com | www.51331d.com | www.c22365.com | 28824f.com | www.3691n.com | 5002400.com | 55155w.com | www.312615.com | 3148.com | www.52303u.com | www.xpj778899.com | 11442007.com | www.303465.com | www.19019m.com | 91019e.com | www.374511.com | www.19yh7.com | 7276776.com | www.320160.com | www.3157e.com | 28839o.com | www.139620.com | www.4996yx.com | 8905j.com | 8547yy.com | www.1113yl.com | www.3983139.com | mm3189.com | www.ylylc02.com | www.67797l.com | dd3405.com | www.9818p.cc | www.433444a.com | 1113865.com | www.544779.com | www.u32939.com | 2595b.com | xpj677z.com | www.7777bj.com | www.44221.com | 30171177.com | www.805733.com | www.f32939.com | 7792m.com | 8030h.com | www.76520c.com | www.82788.com | mg0500.cc | www.031059.com | www.9988gvb.com | www.xpj3378.com | 56988tt.com | www.rcw678.com | www.163a1.com | bet28x.com | 8827ll.com | www.41855.cc | www.xinpujingcaipiao.com | ambyc3.com | 3122uu.com | www.7793e.com | www.063260.com | 500000573.com | 914903.com | www.9478j.com | www.77731j.com | omy88.com | bet36570000.com | www.cp3158.com | www.009289.com | www.28758i.com | 3473e.com | www.330197.com | www.4625.com | www.hg418.com | 588ylw.com | 6261r.com | www.5522l.cc | www.9b008.com | www.182ks.com | tiange1.com | www.186287.com | www.37266m.com | www.62kjw.com | 588vvv.cc | 3178dd.com | www.540707.com | www.hg241.com | www.13090.com | zhcp64.com | 83378z.com | www.374311.com | www.a2418.com | www.0748.cc | www.d67783.com | 4270bb.com | www.012288.com | www.bet73w.com | www.yzcp2024.com | www.hg5878.com | 4189111.com | sjznews.com | www.cp500.pw | www.hg6833.com | www.49200a.com | 5446xx.com | df8ff.com | 54549955.com | www.513.vip | www.wns123h.com | www.048888.com | 4323q.com | 4018k.com | 7334r.com | www.847677.com | www.90555.net | www.yzcp2026.com | www.77537x.com | 3016sss.com | c388n.com | v08199.com | www.lqc4.com | www.a201879.com | www.2y929.com | www.10053344.com | gc8.com | 879.com | q2306.com | www.500021.com | www.71399k.com | www.91779.com | www.861000.com | www.6491t.com | 1383840.com | cq9.com | 08159l.com | www.11djcp.com | www.26878z.com | www.86339l.com | www.2945l.com | www.4261144.com | bwinrrr.com | 7599cc.com | 1966xpj.com | yk802.com | www.444037.com | www.3478s.cc | www.886498.com | www.x69096.com | www.www-58944.com | www.792suncity.com | 22556k.com | 307590.com | 3379j.com | 88052.vip | 88851m.com | www.596709.com | www.3126w.com | www.cq58qp.com | www.sha2211.com | www.k7817.vip | www.jszg22.com | 56787qq.com | 4437008.com | JS1388j.com | www.61655s.com | www.369410.com | www.20166.com | www.936699.com | www8827.com | 5309d.com | xx67890.com | 35442222.com | 875856.com | vnsr33888.com | www.39500i.com | www.507933.com | www.fyyy3.com | www.36788d.com | www.6768992.com | www.xpj53516.com | www.7225t.com | www.5099bb.com | www.77msctyc.com | www.345345.com | www.js60a.com | www.777444a.com | www.6491d.com | www.058hx.com | 88905151.com | 3136mm.com | 111122xx.com | 56787qq.com | 33382h.com | vnb8.com | t99345.am | 18438v.com | 23599.com | 3788.red | hjcp188.com | dhy.net | 9506n.com | 7599bb.com | m01234.com | 3788.red | 888990033.com | 08159c.com | JS1388z.com | btt529g.com | 9287999.com | b5429.com | 99151v.com | 0747hh.com | 3434nnn.com | 9964a.com | www.yh66604.com | www.kim111.com | www.38200m.com | www.338808.com | www.87msc.com | www.opbet.cc | www.pj5633.com | www.xihu77.com | www.c31d.vip | www.255793.com | www.5981j.com | www.115527p.com | www.jsdc9111.com | www.00797b.com | www.js18688.com | www.50054k.com | www.8499g.com | www.ya638.com | www.919309.com | www.401280.com | df8o.com | 7003a.com | huangma13.com | 0615014.com | 3846zzz.com | 6830y.com | www.55555t.com | www.333133h.com | www.amjsty5.com | www.xj666k.com | www.28000b.com | www.99552yy.com | www.ylylc04.com | www.15355r.com | www.902775.com | www.257512.com | 3434rrr.com | 33599dd.com | 2266hhgz.com | 0600n.cc | www.xw66666.com | www.vip355.vip | www.yh95678.com | www.vns6608.com | www.4809v.com | www.41518y.com | www.762918.com | pj900.com | pp3100.com | 3522j.cc | 228888w.com | www.3643b.com | www.okok116.com | www.11vn777.com | www.9989572.com | www.126kc.com | www.223085.com | 5478h.com | am777.cc | 1077pp.com | www.9679900.com | www.gdnmi.com | www.40288v.com | www.60123z.com | www.579031.com | ra333333.com | 0615014.com | 7055000.com | www.7830i.com | www.hg7760.com | www.81508.com | www.5095s.com | www.107501.com | 2613g.com | 80368tt.com | www.vns7777.cc | www.3171113.com | www.777xx.cc | www.ya909.com | v995.com | 22411.com | 2851g.com | www.20209.com | www.huangma29.com | www.66332d.com | www.330985.com | bet365yulecheng871.org | d62365.com | www.hg001111.com | www.834817.com | www.3404.cc | www.163cp1.cc | 89777z.com | 18449455.com | www.22401.com | www.55070u.com | www.50074b.com | www.178673.com | yh888.com | 3169m.com | www.827733.com | www.165422.com | www.663566.com | 00048o.com | c63.cc | www.36607a.com | www.758908.com | www.928621.com | 555v55.com | 2078d.com | www.118893.com | www.14168a.com | www.799200.com | 228888s.com | 6766ii.com | www.x99688.com | www.78680j.com | www.599643.com | 00773hh.com | 6641kk.com | www.hjcp77.com | www.77802s.com | 0109js.com | 2091.com | www.7338007.com | www.780780g.com | www.530126.com | 4647a.com | www.hg2566.biz | www.jz3666.com | www.55kcw.com | ab0034.com | 2613z.com | www.55526n.com | www.60007r.com | 293365.com | g99345.am | www.kj207.com | www.61233y.com | 88021.com | 8827oo.com | www.55526w.com | www.6832t.com | 939000.com | kk3385.com | www.00618i.com | www.c140.vip | ly88888818.com | www.38200p.com | www.834546.com | www.330627.com | ee01234.com | www.902505.com | www.68993239.com | 86811j.com | 915908761.com | www.fc687.com | www.8816i.com | 667766s.com | www.373xpj.com | www.63606q.com | www.178625.com | 33318o.com | www.mgm512.com | www.3126u.com | 5002i.com | www.9068ee.com | www.0343k.com | bet365baijiale34.net | 3379ss.com | www.4963kk.com | www.655021.com | 8344555.com | www.69077.com | www.1368u.cc | 8381j.com | www.zdj70.com | www.858466.com | 7811i.com | www.8494i.com | www.siji07.com | 51200uu.com | www.6033q.com | www.7783066.com | 6766hh.com | 5004sss.com | www.sdoroviy.com | 396396a.com | 0022886.com | www.1754.com | 1607.com | xinhao999.com | www.12136a.com | kb5454.com | www.ylg2222.com | www.flb908.com | 1331cc.com | www.8124t.com | www.13434b.com | 30179900.com | www.330099r.com | www.83033d.com | 8742t.com | www.11777999.com | www.gai06.com | 3405dd.com | www.56655i.com | www.516113.com | 7935.com | www.3032ff.com | 44225156.com | www.2xinhao.com | www.3978d.com | 449649.com | www.500128.com | www.673066.com | 666df8.com | www.73990a.com | rbbet55.com | www.67797o.com | www.15355p.com | x4255.com | www.5504k.com | www.055979.com | 00778x.com | www.11mgm777.com | 4036cc.com | www.hg8056.com | www.451770.com | 99111ll.com | www.735518.com | 71707h.com | www.3650092.com | www.219055.com | www.a8a8789.com | www.68689r.com |